- Joined
- Jun 22, 2017
- Messages
- 4,096
- Reaction score
- 2,087
My brother is getting involved in specialty food export/import in Mexico. While he was there on a business trip, I helped my SIL care for their daughter. So my brother paid me in Mexican Vanilla Beans.
There’s three types of vanilla: Tahitian Madagascar, and Mexican.
Tahitian is very very fragrant. However it’s absolutely flavorless. Really a waste of money.
Madagascar is very flavorful. Many bakers claim it’s the best—better than Mexican vanilla. Which is not true. Vanilla is not native to Madagascar.
The vanilla cultivated in Madagascar is in fact Mexican vanilla. The vanilla and the two regions are exactly the same species of vanilla orchid.
There are very subtle differences due to slight various in soil and climate. Mexican vanilla cultivated in Madagascar has spice notes, while Mexican vanilla has a slightly more woodsy notes.
Mexican vanilla is in fact the world’s best vanilla, whether it’s Mexican vanilla cultivated in Madagascar or in Mexico.
I strongly recommend caution when considering Mexican vanilla extract. Read the label very carefully to ensure it is in fact extract. It should contain Mexican vanilla an alcohol only. It’s best to to purchase Mexican vanilla extract is from a reputable company like Nielsen-Massey. A lot of product labeled “Mexican Vanilla” is an artificial product made with coumarin, derived from the Tonka bean, and no vanilla bean. If you Google Tonka bean it may even come up as “Tonka vanilla bean”. But Tonka bean is not a vanilla orchid. It’s not even a vanilla species. While it has the fragrance of vanilla it it is essentially flavorless. US government has issued a health warning for coumarin.
There’s three types of vanilla: Tahitian Madagascar, and Mexican.
Tahitian is very very fragrant. However it’s absolutely flavorless. Really a waste of money.
Madagascar is very flavorful. Many bakers claim it’s the best—better than Mexican vanilla. Which is not true. Vanilla is not native to Madagascar.
The vanilla cultivated in Madagascar is in fact Mexican vanilla. The vanilla and the two regions are exactly the same species of vanilla orchid.
There are very subtle differences due to slight various in soil and climate. Mexican vanilla cultivated in Madagascar has spice notes, while Mexican vanilla has a slightly more woodsy notes.
Mexican vanilla is in fact the world’s best vanilla, whether it’s Mexican vanilla cultivated in Madagascar or in Mexico.
I strongly recommend caution when considering Mexican vanilla extract. Read the label very carefully to ensure it is in fact extract. It should contain Mexican vanilla an alcohol only. It’s best to to purchase Mexican vanilla extract is from a reputable company like Nielsen-Massey. A lot of product labeled “Mexican Vanilla” is an artificial product made with coumarin, derived from the Tonka bean, and no vanilla bean. If you Google Tonka bean it may even come up as “Tonka vanilla bean”. But Tonka bean is not a vanilla orchid. It’s not even a vanilla species. While it has the fragrance of vanilla it it is essentially flavorless. US government has issued a health warning for coumarin.