How to Make a Larger Genoise Sponge for Layering and Stacking

Joined
Feb 20, 2023
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Hi!!

I bake a genoise sponge which I’ve altered to really like. However I’m having trouble getting the sponge to ‘be bigger’ and I’m not sure how to achieve that.

Recipe

225g sugar/self raising flour/butter
4 eggs
Milk
Flavour

Bake for 25mins on 160

Split into 2 shallow pans but it doesn’t even rise out of the edge!

I tried to same mixture but putting it all in one bigger pan and increasing the bake time but it didn’t seem to have much effect.

I am basically looking to achieve a larger sponge for layers and stacking. Thank you:)
 
Joined
Jan 12, 2020
Messages
1,104
Reaction score
228
Its not even close to genoise. You're missing half the eggs.

in grams its 450 gr egg , 225 gr flour. 225 gr flour.

4 eggs is only 200 grams.

Melted butter or warm water can help if theres a dehydration problem such as baking it on flat sheet trays, I don't bother.
I also don't flavor the sponge, that comes later when I douse it with straight rum, grand marnier or other liqueur.
 
Joined
Feb 20, 2023
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Its not even close to genoise. You're missing half the eggs.

in grams its 450 gr egg , 225 gr flour. 225 gr flour.

4 eggs is only 200 grams.

Melted butter or warm water can help if theres a dehydration problem such as baking it on flat sheet trays, I don't bother.
I also don't flavor the sponge, that comes later when I douse it with straight rum, grand marnier or other liqueur.


You’re right! I thought it was following previous research but after doing that again today whilst trying to troubleshoot I realised it isn’t a genoise, which is fine! I start with a basic recipe then adjust as I research what I’d like to change/improve so am not the best with terminology or history.

other than not getting the rise I want, I don’t have any issues such as dehydration or shallow or risen middles. I use a round pan, and just want a taller cake for my layers/tiers. They come out at maybe 1/2 to 3/4 of an inch currently.
 
Joined
Jun 22, 2017
Messages
4,099
Reaction score
2,087
Hi!!

I bake a genoise sponge which I’ve altered to really like. However I’m having trouble getting the sponge to ‘be bigger’ and I’m not sure how to achieve that.

Recipe

225g sugar/self raising flour/butter
4 eggs
Milk
Flavour

Bake for 25mins on 160

Split into 2 shallow pans but it doesn’t even rise out of the edge!

I tried to same mixture but putting it all in one bigger pan and increasing the bake time but it didn’t seem to have much effect.

I am basically looking to achieve a larger sponge for layers and stacking. Thank you:)

If the cake is rising and setting properly, but not filling the pan, it just means you don’t have enough batter in the pan. You need to scale the recipe to the pan using baker’s percentages.

Add up the total weight of you ingredients.
Divide that number by two.
That is the amount of batter you are using per cake.

Since total weight of batter per cake is not enough to give you the size cake you want, you need to increase the amout of total batter per cake.

If the cake is 3/4 the height desired, then increase the batter by about 15%. If that proves to be too little/too much adjust in 5% increments.

First you need to calculate your baker’s percentages. Since you didn’t list the weight of all your ingredients, I cannot calaculate it.

To calculate the baker’s percentages, divide the weight of each ingredient into the weight of the flour.

Flour 225 g
Butter 225 g
Eggs ?
Milk ?
Extract ?
Salt?

Flour is always 100%

weight butter 225 ÷ flour 225 g = 1 (same as 100%)

weight of eggs ÷ 225 = ?

weight of milk ÷ 225 = ?

weight of extract ÷ 225 and = ?

weight of salt ÷ 225 = ?

Add up the total percentages. That is the total baker’s percentages.

You will need to use the baker’s percentages to calculate how much of each ingredient to use to increase the amount of batter. You use the baker’s percentages to ensure the ratio of each ingredient to the weight of the flour stays consistent.


How to use the baker’s percentages

Since I don’t know the baker’s percentages, I will just make up some numbers

butter 225 ÷ flour 225 g = 1 (same as 100%)

weight of eggs 220 g ÷ 225 = .97 (same as 97%)

weight of milk 250 mL ÷ 225 = 1.11 (same as 111%)

weight of extract 10 ÷ 225 and = 0.04 (same as 4%)

weight of salt ÷ 225 = 0.013 (same as 1.3%)

Add up the percentages of each ingredient for total baker’s percentages
100 Flour
100 Butter
97 eggs
111 milk
4 extract
1.3 salt
413.3 Total baker’s percentages

Now add up the total weight of the batter

225 g flour
225 g butter
220 g eggs
250 g milk
10 g extract
3 g salt

933 g Total weight of batter for 2 cakes

Example
, you want to bake 2 8” cakes. The original recipe total weight is 933 g. Divided by 2, each cake is 466.5 g per cake.

Say you want to increase that by 15% to make a taller cake.

466.5 g cake batter x .15 = 69.97. Round that up to 70 g additional batter

You need to increase the batter amount per cake by 70 g.

466.5 + 70 = 536.5 g. Just round down to 536 grams per cake.

The new amount of batter per cake is 536 g



Step 1: calculate the amount of batter you need

you want 2 8” cakes at 536 g batter each; multiply number of cakes needed by the amount of batter per cake

2 cakes x 536 = 1072 g total batter needed


Total batter needed is 1072 g



Step 2: calculate 1% of the baker’s percentage for each ingredient
  • Divide the total weight of the batter you NEED (1072 g) by the Total Baker’s Percentage (413.3)
1072 ÷ 413.3 = 2.5937 just round down to 2.59. Since it was rounded down, it will give you just under the 1072 g of batter

Multiply baker’s percentages of each ingredient by the multiplier 2.59.

100% flour x 2.59 = 259 g flour
100% butter x 2.59 = 259 g butter
97% eggs x 2.59 = 251.23 g eggs
111% g milk x 2.59 = 287.49 mL milk
4% extract x 2.59 = 10.36 extract
1.3% g salt x 2.59 = 3.36 g salt

New totals:
259 g flour
259 g butter
251.23 g eggs
287.49 mL milk
10.36 extract
3.36 g salt
—————————
1070.44 total weight of batter

each cake will be 535 g of batter verses the original recipe that used 466.5 g batter per cake.





==============================

Just for clarification, genoise is traditionally four ingredients.

General Ratios:
  • Egg 150% - 200%
  • Sugar 100% - 115%
  • Flour/starch 100%
  • Fat 20% - 40% clarified butter


You can add some salt and flavoring (extract, vanilla bean, etc.) There’s a to mixing methods for genoise: hot process and cold process genoise.


Also If you are in the UK, your eggs are not 50 g each. UK and European Union rate egg size on a different scale from US and Canada.

By Code of Federal Regulation (CFR), eggs must meet a MINIMUM size to be included in a grade side. Most large eggs in the US will yield (out of shell) about 50 g. UK/European eggs per size compared to US/Canada yield more since they are larger.

United States
SizeMinimum mass per eggUS weight
Jumbo70.9 g2.5 oz
Extra-Large (XL)63.8 g2.25 oz.
Large (L)56.7 g2 oz.
Medium (M)49.6 g1.75 oz.
Small (S)42.5 g1.5 oz.
Peewee35.4 g1.25 oz.
Canada
SizeMinimum mass per egg
Jumbo70 g
Extra Large63 g
Large56 g
Medium49 g
Europe
SizeMinimum mass per egg
Extra large (XL)73 g
Large (L)63 g
Medium (M)53 g
Small (S)Less than 53 g
 
Joined
Jul 31, 2024
Messages
688
Reaction score
8
To get a larger genoise sponge, try doubling your recipe and using a bigger pan, as a larger batter amount will rise more. Make sure to use cake flour instead of self-raising flour for a lighter texture, and consider adding a bit of baking powder to help with the rise. Ensure your oven is at the right temperature (around 170°C) and grease your pans well. Also, gently fold the batter to keep it airy and let the sponge cool completely before removing it.
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
6,621
Messages
48,534
Members
5,591
Latest member
enigma

Latest Threads

Top